United States v. Alvis F. Denison et al., 71 I.D. 144 (1964)

Marie W. Denison, Individually and as Executrix of the Estate of Alvis F. Denison, Deceased v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 963, D. Ariz. Remanded, 248 F. Supp. 942 (1965).

Leo E. Shoup v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 5822-Phx., D. Ariz. Suit pending.

Reid Smith v. Stewart L. Udall etc., Civil Action No. 1053, D, Ariz, Suit

pending. United States v. Everett Foster et al., 65 I.D. 1 (1958)

Everett Foster et al., v. Fred A. Seaton, Civil Action No. 344–58. Judgment for Defendants, December 5, 1958 (opinion). Affirmed, 271 F. 2d 836 (1959).

No petition.
United States v. Henault Mining Co., 73 I.D. 184 (1966)

Henault Mining Co. v. Harold Tysk et al., Civil Action No. 634, D. Mont. Judgment for Plaintiff, 271 F. Supp. 474 (1967). Appeal taken, October

23, 1967. United States v. Charles H. Henrikson et al., 70 I.D. 212 (1963)

Charles H. Henrikson et al. v. Stewart L. Udall et al., Civil Action No. 41749. N.D. Cal., Southern Division. Judgment for Defendant, May 28, 1964, Affirmed, 350 F. 2d 949 (1965); rehearing den. October 28, 1965. Cert. den.,

380 U.S. 910 (1966). United States v. Independent Quick Silver Co., 72 I.D. 367 (1965)

Independent Quick Silver Co., an Oregon Corp. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 65-590, D. Ore. Judgment for Defendant, 262 F. Supp. 583 (1966).

Appeal taken.
United States v. Richard Dean Lance, 73 I.D. 218 (1966)

Richard Dean Lance v. Stewart L. Udall et al., Civil Action No. 1864, D.

Nev. Suit pending.
United States v. Mary A. Mattey, 67 I.D. 63 (1960)

United States v. Edison R. Nogueira et al., Civil Action No. 65–220-PH, C.D. Cal. Judgment for Defendant, November 16, 1966. Appeal taken, January

9, 1967. United States v. Kenneth McClarty, 71 I.D. 331 (1964)

Kenneth McClarty v. Stewart L. Udall et al., Civil Action No. 2116, E.D. Wash., Southern Division. Judgment for Defendant, May 26, 1966. Appeal

taken, July 13, 1966. United States v. New Jersey Zinc Company, 74 I.D. 191 (1967)

The New Jersey Zinc Corp., a Del. Corp. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action

No. 67-C-404, D. Colo. Suit pending. United States v. E. V. Pressentin and Devisees of the H. S. Martin Estate, 71 I.D. 447 (1964)

E. V. Pressentin, Fred J. Martin, Admin. of H. A. Martin Estate v. Stewart L. (dall and Charles Stoddard, Civil Action No. 1194–65. Suit pending.

United States v. Ollie Mae Shearman et al., 73 I.D. 386 (1966)

United States v. Hood Corporation et al., Civil Action No. 1-67–97, S.D.

Idaho. Suit pending.
United States v. C. F. Snyder et al., 72 I.D. 223 (1965)

Ruth Snyder, Administratrix of the Estate of C. F. Snyder, Deceased et al. v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 66-C-131, D. Colo. Judgment for Plain.

tiff, 267 F. Supp. 110 (1967). Appeal taken, June 14, 1967. E. A. Vaughey, 63 I.D 85 (1956)

E. A. Vaughey v. Fred A. Seaton, Civil Action No. 1744–56. Dismissed by

stipulation, April 18, 1957. No appeal. Burt A. Wackerli et al., 73 I.D. 280 (1966)

Burt & Lueva G. Wa erli al. v. Stewart L. Udall et al., Civil Action No.

1-66–92, D. Idaho, Southern Division. Suit pending. Weardco Construction Corp., 64 I.D. 376 (1957)

Weardco Construction Corp. v. United States, Civil Action No. 278-59-PH, S. D. Cal. Judgment for Plaintiff, October 26, 1959. Satisfaction of judg

ment entered February 9, 1960. United States v. Vernon 0.& Ina C. White, 72 I.D. 522 (1965)

Vernon O. White & Ina C. White v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 1

65–122, D. Idaho. Judgment for Defendant, January 6, 1967. Appeal taken. Frank Winegar, Shell Oil Co. and D. A. Shale Inc., 74 I.D. 161 (1967)

Shell Oil Co. et al. v. Udall, et al., Civil Action No. 67-C-321, D. Colo.

Judgment for Plaintiff (September 18, 1967). No appeal. Estate of Wook-Kah-Nah, Comanche Allottee No. 1927, 65 I.D. 436 (1958)

Thomas J. Huff, Adm. with will annexed of the Estate of Wook-Kah-Nah, Deceased, Comanche Enrolled Restricted Indian No. 1927 v. Jane Asenap, Wilfred Tabbytite, J. R. Graves, Examiner of Inheritance, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Department of the Interior of the United States of America, and Earl R. Wiseman, District Director of Internal Revenue, Civil Action No. 8281, W. D. Okla. The court dismissed the suit as to the Examiner of Inheritance, and the Plaintiff dismissed the suit without prejudice as to the other Defendants in the case.

Thomas J. Huff, Adm. with will annexed of the Estate of Wook-Kah-Nah v. Stewart L. Udall, Civil Action No. 2595-60. Judgment for Defendant, June 5, 1962. Remanded, 312 F. 2d 358 (1962).

TABLE OF CASES CITED

29

Page

Pago Abbett Electric Co., IBCA-170 Associated Oil Company, 51 (Aug. 12, 1960), 60–2 BCA par.

L.D. 241 (1925)

234 2744. 225 51 L.D. 308 (1925)

234 Adams v. United States, 318 F. Associate Solicitor's Opinion, 64

2d 861, 870 (9th Cir. 1963)--195, 390 I.D. 351, 352 (1957) --- 165, 166, 168 Aerodex, Inc., ASBCA No. 7121, A. S. Wikstrom, Inc., IBCA1962 BCA par. 3492 (1962)--

226

466-11-64 (Mar. 23, 1965), Alaska Copper Company, 43

65-1 BCA par. 4725.. L.D. 257 (1914).

251 Atherton Sinclair Burlingham Alaska, State of, Andrew J.

et al., 71 I.D. 126, 128 (1964). 402 Kalerak, Jr., 73 I.D. 1 (1966) -- 149 Atlantic City, Elliot v., 149 Fed. A. L. Dougherty Overseas, Inc.,

849, 853 (C.C.D.N.J. 1907) - 420 ASBCA No. 11163 (Mar. 24, Attorney General's Opinion, 28 1966), 66–1 BCA par. 5478.. 73 Op. Atty. Gen. 524, 525

252 Alexander, Robert E., and

29 Op. Atty. Gen. 303, 305, Richard J. Neutra, IBCA-408

306 (1912)--

251, 252 (Oct. 18, 1964), 71 I.D. 375,

30 Op. Atty. Gen. 263, 269 1964 BCA par. 4485.. 310 (1914).

251 American Cement Corporation, Babington, Charles J., 71 I.D. IBCA-496–5–65 and IBCA

110 (1964)-

377 578–7–66 (Sept. 21, 1966), 73 Baker v. Potter, 223 La. 274, I.D. 266, 66-2 BCA par. 5849,

65 So. 2d 598 (1952)-

172 on reconsideration, 74 I.D. 15, Banzhaf, The Swan Co. v., 59 66-2 BCA par. 6065.- 308, 350

I.D. 262, 270,

274,

275 American Investment Co. of

(1946)

65, 66, 70 Lichtenstein, 134 F.

Barden v. Northern Pacific R.R. Supp. 857, 861 (E.D. Mo.

Page

Page B & E Constructors, Inc., Carlin, Fisher v., 346 P. 2d 641 IBCA-547-2–66 (Aug. 28,

(Ore. 1959) -

76 1967), 67-2 BCA par. 6548.-- 354 Castle v. Womble, 19 L.D. 455, Best v. Humboldt Placer Mining

457 (1894)-------- 194, 293, 388, 390 Co., 371 U.S. 334, 336 (1963) 194, Cataract Gold Mining Company

293, 390

et al., 43 L.D. 248, 254 (1914). 196,298 Bianchi v. United States, 373 Central Pacific RR. Co. v. ValenU.S. 709 (1963)-

19
tine, 11 L.D. 238 (1890)

289 Blakemore, Herbert H. et al.,

Cerro Copper & Brass Company, 72 I.D. 248 (1965)-

163

GSBCA No, 1964 (Oct. 26, Blumer, Iowa Railroad Land

1966), 66-2 BCA par. 5935.- 160 Co. v., 206 U.S. 482 (1907). 129, 131 Champlin Oil and Refining ComBoard of Sup’rs of Webster

pany et al., 66 I.D. 26 (1959) -- 235 County, Childs et al. v., 128

Charles H. Tompkins Co., So. 338 (Sup. Ct. Miss. 1930)- 177

ASBCA No. 2983, 57-2 BCA Boeing Airplane Company v.

par. 1522 (1957)-----

226 Coggleshall, 280 F. 2d 654,

Chester Barrett,

The 660 (D.C. Cir. 1960)--

d/b/a 183

American Tank Company, Boeing Company, O'Keefe v.,

IBCA-429–3–64 (Apr. 38 F.R.D. 329 (S.D.N.Y.

7,

1966), on motion for recon1965)-

164 Boesche v. Udall, 373 U.S. 472

sideration, 66-1 BCA par.
5503_.

118 (1963)-

396 Brady, John G., 26 L. D. 305

Childs et al. v. Board of Sup’rs of (1898).

13
Webster County, 128 So. 338

177 Braffet, State of Utah, Pleasant

(Sup. Ct. Miss. 1930) -Valley Coal Company, Inter

Choctaw and Chickasaw Nations, venor v., 49 L.D. 212, 215,

Herron v., 228 F. 2d 830 (10th 216, 218 (1922).

83, 84
Cir. 1956)

420 Braffet, Work v., 276 U.S. 560 Chrisman v. Miller, 197 U.S. (1928).

83 313, 322 (1905) ----194, 293, 390, 396 Braswell Motor Freight Lines, Christy Corporation, IBCA-461Inc., Davis v., 363 F. 2d 600,

10-64 and IBCA-569–5–66 603, 604 (5th Cir. 1966)-

164 (June 20, 1966), 66-1 BCA par. Brown v. Clements, 44 U.S. 5630)

24 (3 How.) 650. 663 (1845)-- 395 Cissna, Stockley v., 119 Fed. Brown, Mary E., 62 I.D. 107

812, 831 (6th Cir. 1902)------ 420 (1955)--

145

City Bank Farmers Trust Co. Brown, R. G. Jr. and Company,

et al. v. United States, 47 F. IBCA-356 (July 26, 1963),

Supp. 98, 103 (Ct. Cl. 1942) --- 167 1963 BCA par. 3799...

337

Clark, Aktiebolaget Vargos et al. Burke v. Southern Pacific RR.

V., 8 F.R.D. 635, 636 (D.D.C. Co., 234 U.S. 669 (1914)----- 289

1949) -Buttram, Taylor v., 111 So. 2d

Clarke v. Clarke, 178 U.S. 186, 576 (La. App. 2d Cir. 1959) -- 171

191 (1900)

170 Calument Canal and Improvement Co., Kean v., 190 U.S.

Clarke, Clarke v., 178 U.S. 186,

417 452, 461 (1903)

170

191 (1900)--Calvada Inc., ASBCA No. 2062,

Clements, Brown v., 44 U.S. 56-2 BCA par. 1033 (1956) -- 227 (3 How.) 650, 663 (1845).-.

395 Cameron v. United States, 252

Coggleshall, Boeing Airplane U.S. 450, 452, 459–460 (1920)

Company v., 280 F. 2d 654, 194, 205 660 (D.C. Cir. 1960)--

183

186

150,