Page images
PDF
EPUB

made by the board of directors of the insured depository institution. A person will be considered to have such required expertise if the person has significant executive, professional, educational, or regulatory experience in financial, auditing, accounting, or banking matters as determined by the board of directors. Significant experience as an officer or member of the board of directors or audit committee of a financial services company would satisfy these criteria.

34. Large Customers. Any individual or entity (including a controlling person of any such entity) which, in the determination of the board of directors, has such significant direct or indirect credit or other relationships with the institution, the termination of which likely would materially and adversely affect the institution's financial condition or results of operations, should be considered a "large customer" for purposes of § 363.5(b).

35. Access to Counsel. The audit committee should be able to retain counsel at its discretion without prior permission of the institution's board of directors or its management. Section 36 does not preclude advice from the institution's internal counsel or regular outside counsel. It also does not require retaining or consulting counsel, but if the committee elects to do either, it also may elect to consider issues affecting the counsel's independence. Such issues would include whether to retain or consult only counsel not concurrently representing the institution or any affiliate, and whether to place limitations on any counsel representing the institution concerning matters in which such counsel previously participated personally and substantially as outside counsel to the committee.

36. Forming and Restructuring Audit Committees. Audit committees should be formed within four months of the effective date of this part. Some institutions may have to restructure existing audit committees to comply with this part. No regulatory action will be taken if institutions restructure their audit committees by the earlier of their next annual meeting of stockholders, or one year from the effective date of this part.

OTHER

37. Modifications of Guidelines. The FDIC Board of Directors has delegated to the Director of the FDIC's Division of Supervision authority to make and publish in the FEDERAL REGISTER minor technical amendments to the Guidelines in this appendix (including the attached Agreed Upon Procedures in Schedule A to this appendix), in consultation with the other appropriate federal banking agencies, to reflect the practical experience gained from implementation of this part. It is not anticipated any such modification would be effective until affected institutions have been given reasonable advance notice of the modification. Any material modification

or amendment will be subject to review and approval of the FDIC Board of Directors.

SCHEDULE A TO APPENDIX A-AGREED UPON PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING COMPLIANCE WITH DESIGNATED LAWS

This schedule A is attached to the Guidelines and Interpretations issued by the FDIC as appendix A to 12 CFR part 363 adopted to implement section 36 of the FDI Act.

The Agreed Upon Procedures set forth in this schedule are referred to in guideline 19. They should be followed by the institution's independent public accountant (or, with respect to the procedures set forth in section I below, by the institution's internal auditor if the accountant is to perform the procedures set forth in section II) in order to permit the accountant to report on the extent of compliance with the Designated Laws (defined in guideline 12, and more specifically identified below) as required by section 36(e) (1) and (2).

Additional guidance concerning the role of the institution, its internal auditor, and its independent public accountant in assessing the institution's compliance with the Designated Laws is set forth in the Guidelines. All terms not otherwise defined in this schedule have the respective meanings ascribed to them in this part, the Guidelines in this appendix, and professional accounting and auditing literature.

Section I-Procedures for Individual
Institutions

The following information should be obtained, and the indicated procedures should be performed, by the institution's independent public accountant in accordance with generally accepted standards for attestation engagements, or by the institution's internal auditor if the procedures set forth in section II of this schedule are to be performed by the accountant.

A. Loans to Insiders

1. Designated Laws. The following laws and regulations (Designated Insider Laws) should be read:

(a) The laws codified at 12 U.S.C. 375, 375a, 375b, 376, 1468(b), 1828(j)(2), 1828(j)(3)(B), 1817(k), and 1972; and

(b) The regulations set forth at 12 CFR 23.5, part 31, 211.3(b)(4), part 215, 337.3, 349.3, 563.43, and 935.2.

2. Information and Procedures. Obtain from management of the institution, and read, the following information for the institution's most recent fiscal year through the date of the attestation report, and perform the procedures indicated with respect to such information:

[ocr errors][merged small]

of the meetings of the board and its committees; reports of examination, supervisory agreements, and enforcement actions issued by the institution's primary federal and state regulators, if applicable; all public documents filed under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 with the FDIC, SEC, Federal Reserve Board, OCC, or OTS; and annual reports filed by insiders identifying their related interests as required by 12 CFR 215.7. Procedure:

(1) Read the foregoing information.

(ii) Trace and agree each disclosed insider loan and other extension of credit to see that it is included on the list of Insider Transactions.

b. Calculations. Obtain management's calculation of the greater of 5 percent of the institution's year-end capital and unimpaired surplus or $25,000.

Procedure: Recalculate for mathematical accuracy, and trace amounts used in management's calculations to the institution's year-end Call Report or TFR.

c. Policies and Procedures. Obtain the institution's written policies and procedures concerning its compliance with the Designated Insider Laws, including any written "Code of Ethics" or "Conflict of Interest" policy statements. If the institution has no written policies and procedures, obtain a narrative from management that describes the methods for complying with such laws, and includes provisions similar to those listed below.

Procedure: Ascertain that the policies and procedures include, or incorporate by reference, provisions consistent with the Designated Insider Laws for:

(i) Defining terms;

(ii) Prohibiting and restricting loans to insiders (i.e., directors, executive officers and principal shareholders and their related interests);

(iii) Maintaining records of loans to insiders;

(iv) Requiring reports and disclosures by the institution and by executive officers, directors, and principal shareholders;

(v) Disseminating policy information; (vi) Revising policies to reflect subsequent changes in the law;

(vii) Educating employees about the legal requirements and management's related policies and procedures;

(viii) Prior approval of the board of directors or its committees, as appropriate; and (ix) Reporting insider loans to regulatory agencies on the institution's Call Report or TFR.

d. Insider Transactions. Obtain a list of loans or other extensions of credit to insiders (including their related interests) during the fiscal year and management's written representations regarding:

(1) The completeness of the list, and

(ii) Whether the terms of insider transactions are comparable to those that would have been available to unaffiliated third parties.

Procedure: Select a sample of the insider transactions from the list. For each transaction in the sample selected:

(1) Ascertain that each executive officer and principal shareholder (or related interest) has reported annually to the board of directors, on or before January 31 of the following year, any indebtedness to correspondent banks, and that such report states:

(a) The maximum amount of indebtedness during the previous calendar year;

(b) The amount of indebtedness outstanding 10 days prior to report filing; and

(c) A description of the loan terms and conditions, including the rate or range of interest rates, original amount and date, maturity date, payment terms, security, and any unusual terms or conditions.

(2) (a) Trace and agree amounts outstanding by insiders to the schedule aggregating indebtedness of all insiders on the institution's year-end Call Report or TFR;

(b) Obtain from management documentation that indicates whether the specific extensions of credit, at the option of the institution, will become due and payable at any time that the insider is indebted to any other insured institution in an aggregate amount greater than the amount specified for a category of credit in 12 CFR 215.5(c);

(c) Obtain from management a copy of the institution's written notification to the insider to ascertain whether the insider has been informed of the reporting requirements relative to insider transactions and has acknowledged such requirements;

(d) If the credit exceeds the lesser of the calculation obtained in paragraph 2b. or $500,000, read the minutes of the meetings of the board of directors and determine whether the minutes indicate that the credit was approved in advance by the board and the insider abstained from participating directly or indirectly in voting on the transactions; and

(e) Obtain management's calculated legal lending limit for the credit and ascertain whether the amount of the credit exceeds such limit.

(3) For executive officers, directors, and principal shareholders of the institution included in the sample, obtain a written history of the insider's overdrafts for the year and obtain management's representation whether that history is complete. In addition,

(a) Inquire whether cash items for the individual are being held by the institution to prevent an overdraft, and

(b) Trace and agree subsequent payment by the insider of the insider's overdrafts to records of the account at the institution.

(4) For overdrafts of executive officers and directors included in the sample that are being paid by the institution for the executive officer and director on an account at the institution:

(a) Trace and agree to a written, pre-authorized, interest-bearing extension of credit plan that specifies a method of repayment; or,

(b) Trace and agree to a written, pre-authorized transfer of funds from another account of the insider at the institution; or,

(c) For aggregate amounts of $1,000 or less, obtain a written representation from management that

(1) It believes the overdraft was inadvertent,

(ii) The account was overdrawn in each case for less than 5 business days, and

(iii) The institution charged the executive officer and director the same fee that it would charge any other customer in similar circumstances.

(5) For extensions of credit to an executive officer selected, ascertain that each credit

was:

(a) Preceded by submission of financial statements;

(b) Promptly reported to the board of directors; and

(c) Made subject to the condition, as specified in the note or other evidence of indebtedness, that the extension of credit will become, at the option of the institution, due and payable at any time that the executive officer is indebted to other insured institutions in an aggregate amount greater than the executive officer would be able to borrow from the institution.

(6) Based on the types of transactions in the sample selected, select a sample of similar transactions with persons who are not insiders of the institution or its affiliates as of the same dates or within two weeks of the insider transaction. Compare the terms of the transactions with the persons not affiliated with the institution to those with insiders, and note in the findings any material differences in the terms favorable to insiders compared to the terms of the transactions with persons not affiliated with the institution or its affiliates.

(7) Aggregate the indebtedness to executive officers, directors, and principal shareholders of the institution and to their related interests from the list obtained as of the end of the fiscal year and one other day selected during the year. Compare this total with 100 percent of the institution's unimpaired capital and surplus at the one day selected during the year and the end of its fiscal year. (The unimpaired capital and surplus calculated from the most recent Call Report or TFR may be used, unless there is reason to believe that a significant change has taken place between the dates.) Report any excess as an exception in the findings.

e. Executive Officers' Reports. Obtain a list of all written reports made by executive officers of the institution concerning debt with other insured institutions, and management's representation concerning the completeness of such list.

Procedure: Select a sample of written reports. For reports selected, note any reported aggregate extensions of credit in excess of the amounts management represents that the executive officer would have been able to borrow from the reporting institution and whether the report was made within 10 days of the date the indebtedness reached such a level. Obtain management's calculation of

(1) The aggregate amount of loans and other extensions or lines of credit to the executive officer and

(ii) 2.5 percent of the institution's capital and unimpaired surplus.

Recalculate management's computations for mathematical accuracy and trace amounts used in management's computations to the institution's Call Report or TFR. Ascertain whether the aggregate amount of the credits for the executive officer exceeds the greater of 2.5 percent of the institution's capital and unimpaired surplus or $25,000, but in no event more than $100,000, unless such credits are used to finance the education of the executive officer's children or the officer's principal residence. If the credit extended is a real estate loan, obtain documentation for the credit and note whether such documentation contains representations that:

(1) The purpose of the credit is for the purchase, construction, maintenance, or improvement of the executive officer's principal residence;

(ii) The credit is secured by a first lien on the residence; and

(iii) the executive officer owns or expects to own the residence after the extension of credit.

B. Dividend Restrictions

1. Designated Laws. The following federal laws and regulations (Designated Dividend Laws) should be read:

(a) The laws codified at 12 U.S.C. 56, 60, 1467(a)(f), 18310; and

(b) The regulations set forth at 12 CFR 5.61, 5.62, 6.6, 7.6120, 208.19, and 563.134.

2. Information and Procedures. Obtain from management of the institution, and read, the following information for the institution's most recent fiscal year through the date of the attestation report, and perform the procedures indicated with respect to such information:

a. Management's Assessment. Obtain management's assessment of the institution's compliance with the Designated Dividend Laws and any applicable state laws and regulations cited in management's assessment.

Also obtain management's written representation whether dividends declared comply with the legal limitations and any restrictions on dividend payments under any supervisory agreements, orders, or resolution of any regulatory agency (including a description of the nature of any such agreement, order, or resolution).

b. Policies and Procedures. Obtain the institution's written policies and procedures concerning its compliance with the Designated Dividend Laws. If the institution has no written policies and procedures, obtain from the institution a narrative that describes the institution's methods for complying with Designated Dividend Laws, includes provisions similar to those below.

Procedure: Ascertain whether the policies and procedures include, or incorporate by reference, provisions which are consistent with the Designated Dividend Laws. For banks and savings institutions, these would include capital limitation tests, including section 38 of the FDI Act, earnings limitation tests, transfers from surplus to undivided profits, and restrictions imposed under any supervisory agreements, resolutions, or orders of any federal or state bank regulatory agency. For savings associations, include prior notification to the OTS.

c. Board Minutes. Obtain the minutes of the meetings of the board of directors for the most recent fiscal year to ascertain whether dividends (either paid or unpaid) have been declared.

Procedure: Trace and agree total dividend amounts to the general ledger records and the institution's appropriate Call Reports or TFRS filed with regulators.

d. Calculation. Obtain management's computation of the amount at which declaration of a dividend would cause the institution to be undercapitalized.

Procedure: Recalculate management's computation (for mathematical accuracy) and compare management's calculations to the amount of any dividend declared to determine whether it exceeded the amount.

e. National and State Member Banks. Obtain management's computation concerning its compliance with 12 U.S.C. 56, "Capital Limitation Test," 12 U.S.C. 60, "The Earnings Limitation Test," and transfers from surplus to undivided profits after payment of the dividends referenced in paragraph 2c. above.

Procedure: Recalculate management's computations (for mathematical accuracy) and compare management's calculations to the standards defined in the test set forth in paragraph 2d. above to ascertain whether the dividends declared fall under the permissible level under this standard. If dividends are not permissible under such standard, ascertain if the dividends were declared under approval of the appropriate federal banking agency or any other exception. If not, report the exception in the findings.

f. Savings Associations. Obtain management's documentation of the OTS determination whether the institution is a Tier 1, Tier 2, or Tier 3 savings institution and management's computation of its capital ratio after declaration of dividends under the Tier determined by the OTS. For dividends declared, obtain a copy of the savings institution's notification to the OTS to ascertain whether notification was made at least 30 days before payment of any dividends.

Procedure: Recalculate management's computation (for mathematical accuracy) and trace amounts used by management in its calculation to the institution's TFRS.

Section II-Procedures for Independent Public Accountant

If the internal auditor has performed the procedures set forth in section I, the following procedures may be performed by the independent public accountant if neither the FDIC nor the appropriate federal banking agency has objected in writing. If the procedures in section I have been performed by an internal auditor employed by a holding company, such procedures should be applied to each subsidiary institution (a Covered Subsidiary) subject to this part. The report of procedures performed and list of exceptions found by the internal auditor, identifying the institution with respect to which any exception was found, should be submitted to the audit committee of the board of directors.

A. Review of Designated Laws. The Designated Insider Laws and Designated Dividend Laws applicable to the institution should be read.

B. Information and Procedures. Obtain from management of the institution, and read, the following information for the institution's most recent fiscal year through the date of the attestation report, and perform the procedures indicated with respect to such information:

1. Designated Laws. Read Section I of this schedule. Obtain management's assessment contained in its management report on the institution's or holding company's compliance with the Designated Laws.

2. Internal Auditor's Workpapers. If an internal auditor performed the procedures in Section I, obtain the internal auditor's workpapers documenting the performance of those procedures on the institution, including all Covered Subsidiaries, and the chief internal auditor's written representation that:

(a) The internal auditor or audit staff, if applicable, performed the procedures listed in section I on the institution and each Covered Subsidiary;

(b) The internal auditor tested a sufficient number of transactions governed by the Designated Laws so that the testing was rep

resentative of the institution's or Covered Subsidiary's volume of transactions;

(c) The workpapers accurately reflect the work performed by the internal auditor and, if applicable, the internal audit staff;

(d) The workpapers obtained are complete; and

(e) The internal auditor's report, which describes the procedures performed for the preceding fiscal year as well as the internal auditor's findings and exceptions noted, has been presented to the institution's audit committee.

Procedure: Compare the workpapers to the procedures that are required to be performed under section I, and report as an exception any procedures not documented and any procedures for which the sample size is not sufficient. Compare the exceptions and errors listed by the internal auditor in its report to the audit committee to those found in the workpapers, and report as an exception any exception or error found in the internal auditor's workpapers and not listed in the internal auditor's list of exceptions.

C. Testing by Independent Public Accountant. The accountant should perform the procedures listed in section I on a representative sample of the transactions of the institution and Covered Subsidiaries to which each of the Designated Laws applies. The sample tested at each institution, or Covered Subsidiary, should be at least 20 percent of the size of the sample tested by the internal auditor at such institution, although samples selected should be from the population at large. If the testing is being performed on a holding company with more than one Covered Subsidiary, the sample tested for each Designated Law should include transactions from each such subsidiary at least every other fiscal year. If the holding company has more than eight Covered Subsidiaries, the sample of transactions tested for each Designated Law should include transactions from each such subsidiary at least every third fiscal year.

D. Reports Concerning Holding Companies. Only one report of any exceptions noted from application of the procedures in section II performed by the independent public accountant on all Covered Subsidiaries of a holding company should be filed as required by guideline 3, but the report should identify, for each exception or error noted, the identity of the Covered Subsidiary to which it relates.

Sec.

PART 364-STANDARDS FOR SAFETY AND SOUNDNESS

364.100 Purpose.

364.101 Standards for safety and soundness.

APPENDIX A TO PART 364-Interagency Guidelines Establishing Standards for Safety and Soundness

AUTHORITY: 12 U.S.C. 1819 (Tenth), 1831p-1.

SOURCE: 60 FR 35685, July 10, 1995, unless outherwise noted.

$364.100 Purpose.

Section 39 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act requires the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation to establish safety and soundness standards. Pursuant to section 39, this part establishes safety and soundness standards by guideline.

$364.101 Standards for safety and

soundness.

The Interagency Guidelines Establishing Standards for Safety and Soundness prescribed pursuant to section 39 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1831p-1), as set forth as appendix A to this part apply to all insured state nonmember banks and to state-licensed insured branches of foreign banks, that are subject to the provisions of section 39 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act.

APPENDIX A TO PART 364-INTERAGENCY GUIDELINES ESTABLISHING STANDARDS FOR SAFETY AND SOUNDNESS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. Introduction

A. Preservation of existing authority.
B. Definitions.

II. Operational and Managerial Standards A. Internal controls and information systems.

B. Internal audit system.
C. Loan documentation.
D. Credit underwriting.
E. Interest rate exposure.

F. Asset growth.

G. [Reserved].

H. [Reserved].

I. Compensation, fees and benefits.

III. Prohibition on Compensation That Constitutes an Unsafe and Unsound Practice A. Excessive compensation.

B. Compensation leading to material financial loss.

« PreviousContinue »