Page images

partisan basis, proposed enabling legislation that would create a State air pollution control agency, one that would be similar to pollution control agencies now existing in the other Sates. The legislature affirmed the concern of the Missoula County delegation and passed the bill. However, the Governor rejected action of the legislature and vetoed the bill.

Twenty-five States have enacted air pollution legislation. Only in my State has this desirable enabling legislation been vetoed by the Governor. I want to emphasize to this subcommittee that—despite the veto-the people of Montana, their local officials, their State legislature and their Senators believe in the air pollution abatement program.

I am sure that early next year the legislature will again pass enabling legislation and my Governor will have another opportunity to join the bipartisan effort to clean up air pollution at that time.

Some States have more serious pollution problems than does Montana. However, the people of Missoula County, and neighboring Granite County, where serious fluoride pollution exists, would believe that their problem is as serious as that in any part of the Nation.

The veto of the Governor of Montana, with its seeming lack of concern for the health and welfare of the people of Montana, must raise questions regarding the validity of the States assuming primary responsibility in the area of air pollution control.

This is why I am before the committee, Mr. Chairman, the neglect of the States to carry out their responsibility, so we must assume that responsibility for control of air and water pollution.

The 1963 Federal Clean Air Act states that “the prevention and control of air pollution at its source is the primary responsibility of State and local governments.” This law and its 1965 amendments contain a variety of services to assist States and local governments in meeting their responsibilities. Many States and communities have been quick to take advantage of Federal assistance.

Mr. Chairman, we have a great deal of talk these days about Federal assistance. The President and Governor Rockefeller and others have talked about this business of creative or cooperative federalism, you know. We discuss the Federal grants-in-aid, which developed in the time of Franklin Roosevelt. We are trying to give the States an opportunity to help themselves and by these grants-in-aid we are giving them the responsibility to carry out these programs. At the same time if they don't meet that responsibility we say the Federal Government then will take care of it,

Montana has received a $10,000 grant to develop a State control program. This grant will continue for a second year which ends June 30, 1967. If Montana, by that time, has not enacted legislation setting up a workable State air pollution control program, no further Federal control funds can be provided the State.

Let me add here, that this money so far awarded to Montana is not going to abate any air pollution but hopefully will finance planning necessary for the establishment of a control program. It will take considerably greater funds to assist in abating Montana's air pollution problems.

Enactment of the State air pollution control program would have made available to Montana considerably more than the $10,000 annu

[merged small][ocr errors]

ally referred to above. Montana would be entitled to its full share of program grant funds which, of course, could not exceed 1212 percent of the $5 million allocated for this purpose.

These funds would help the State to actively pursue control methods, establish air pollution standards, and police this critical area. Currently, however, the citizens of Montana are not protected from intrastate air pollution.

I firmly support the right of industries to freely arrive at what could be considered business decisions. However, there are two more important considerations. As a public official, my primary responsibility is to the health and welfare of my constituents. AŬ of us, industry included, have an obligation in a free society to protect and maintain the resources on which that society depends.

Throughout the Nation many, many industries have installed pollution control devices, often at very great expense and frequently without hope of having that expense increase their income. These industries have recognized their social responsibility and deserve our high praise for their positive control actions.

They have recognized that the approximately $11 billion a year that air pollution costs the Nation is too high a price to pay for noncontrol. They have also recognized that we cannot continue to pay the priceless costs incurred by damage to human health and welfare.

Mr. Chairman, I once again want to congratulate you, specifically, and other members of the subcommittee, for the work you have done, and are doing, on the problem of air pollution.

The public awareness thus created is rapidly motivating our States and communities to provide and plan for adequate air pollution control.

Their response to the services provided by the Federal Clean Air Act and its 1965 amendments is heartening More States and communities should take advantage of this legislation that is designed to assist them with their pollution problems. When the time comes in our Nation that we have turned the tide against the air pollution problems not confronting us, I am aware that it will be said that an immeasurable contribution toward resolving these problems was made by this subcommittee.

Thank you.

do the job.

Senator Muskie. Thank you, Senator. I would like to emphasize two points which you made. First, the point that our current clean air legislation is based upon the assumption that the States ought to deal with this problem, and to that end the legislation provides assistance to the States to help them The legislation before us would provide additional assistance to the States

. I think the testimony before these hearings will indicate there has been an encouraging response on the part of many States. Many of them have not responded. So, it is good to have your testimony on

I would agree with you that if the States do not respond, communities do not respond, then Congress will face an increasing responsibility to act in behalf of the Nation's whole.

It is very important that the States rise to this challenge. The second point that you made that I would like to emphasize is the fact that it has been the practice of this subcommittee to conduet

that point.

hearings, to open up areas of inquiry unrelated to pending legislation. We are this week hearing a great deal of useful and important testimony on specific pollutants because we want to know at an early stage, (rat least as early a stage as possible of the threats to health or lack of threats to health of specific pollutants.

We will hear something this morning about beryllium, something Huore about lead to add to the testimony which we heard yesterday. We like to conduct hearings of this kind unrelated to specific legislation so that we can receive testimony and information in an open minded fashion, so that we can enter into our approach to the problem without prejudgments.

We are going to let the facts lead us. Some of the facts we are getting of course are disputed. We are going to have to choose, based on judgments and based upon the competence of witnesses who come before us.

These two points you have made I think deserve emphasis. Again may I congratulate you, Senator Metcalf, for the very important support you have given to the work of this committee.

Senator METCALF. Mr. Chairman, I want to emphasize again, I come from a sparsely populated State. The State of Montana is the fourth largest State in the Union. We have about three quarters of a million people in that State. And yet this problem of air pollution is a problem in my State just as much as it is a problem in the very heavily populated states from whom you have heard testimony.

The failure of the Governor of the State of Montana to cooperate with an air pollution problem demonstrates the need for this Federal legislation.

Senator MUSKIE. Thank you very much, Senator Metcalf.
Senator METCALF. Thank you.

Senator MUSKIE. Our next witness this morning is a distinguished witness, a worker in the field of air pollution research, Dr. Harriet L. Ilardy, assistant medical director, Occupational Medical Service of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Dr. Hardy, it is a pleasure and a privilege to welcome you this morning.

Dr. ILIRDY. Thank you.

Senator MUSKIE. I might say we will include in the record as docilmentation of Dr. Hardy's background in this field her curriculum vitae and a list of approximately 90 publications involving her word.

(The documents referred to follow :)


Birth: September 23, 1906, Arlington, Massachusetts.
Education :

Kent Place School, Summit. V.J., Graduated. 1924.
Wellesley College, Wellesley, Mass., A.B., 1928.
Cornell University Medical School, M.D., 1932.

Philadelphia General Hospital, 1932–1934.
Diplomate of the National Board of Medical Examiners, 1937.
Diplomate of the American Board of Preventive Medicine, 19.5.).
Physician, Northfield Seminary, East Northfield, Mass., and engaged in private

practice, 1934–1939. Physician, Franklin County Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Children,

193.1.39. Initiated Pediatric Clinic, Franklin County Hospital, Greenfield, Mass., 1937. College Physician and Head of Dept. of Health Education, Radcliffe College,

Cambridge, Mass., 1939-1945.

Graduate Assistant in Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, 1940-1943.
Assistant in Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, 1943–1950.
Assistant Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital, 1950–1951.
Associate Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital, 1951-
Chief, Occupational Medical Clinic, Massachusetts General Hospital, Feb.

Assistant District Health Officer, Division of Epidemiology, Mass. Dept. of

Public Health, Feb. 1945-Sept. 1945.
Physician, Mass. Division of Occupational Hygiene, Dept. of Labor and Indus-

tries, Sept. 1945-Jan. 1948; Jan. 1949-May 1949.
Health Division Group Leader, Los Alamos Scientific Lab. of the Atomic Energy

Commission, Los Alamos, New Mexico, Jan. 1948-Jan. 1949.
Associate Physician, in charge of Occupational Medical Service, Medical Dept.,

Mass. Institute of Technology, May 1949-June 1950,
Assistant Medical Director in charge of Occupational Medical Service, Med.

Dept., Mass. Institute of Technology, June 1950-
Assistant in Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Oct. 1942-July 1943.
Instructor in Industrial Hygiene, Dept. of Industrial Hygiene, Harvard School

of Public Health, July 1947-1952.
Clinical Associate in Preventive Medicine, Harvard Medical School, May 1952-

Lecturer in Dept. of Civil & Sanitary Engineering, M.I.T., June 1951-1954 ; 1961-

Assistant Professor of Preventive Medicine, Harvard Medical School, 1956-1958.
Associate Professor of Preventive Medicine, Harvard Medical School, 1958–1959.
Lecturer on Medicine, Harvard Medical School, 1959
Lecturer in Medicine, Tufts Medical School, 1955–1965.
Consultant, Division of Biology and Medicine, Atomic Energy Commission, 1949–

Consultant, Los Alamos Scientific Lab., Atomic Energy Commission, 1949
Consultant, Atomic Research Center, Ames, Iowa, 1949-
Consultant. Mass. Division of Occupational Hygiene, 1949–1954.
Consultant. Committee on Social and Occupational Health, World Health Orga-

nization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1951-
Consultant, International Labour Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Senior Consultant in Occupational Medicine, Lemuel Shattuck Hospital, Boston,

Mass., 195.5
c'onsultant in Internal Medicine, Veterans Administration Hospital, Boston,

Mass., 1961-
Editorial Board, Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics.
Director, Course on Environmental Medicine, American College of Physicians,

Attached Worker, Dept. of Occupational Health, London School of Hygiene,

London, 1963.
Member. Permanent Commission, International Association on Occupational
Health, 1966.

American Medical Association, 1934-1950.
Massachusetts Medical Society-Member, Committee on Occupational

Health, 1935
Active Member, Association of American Physicians (1919 -),

Sigma Xi (hon,), 1944
Delta Omega (hon.), 1950.
Phi Beta Kappa, Wellesley College (hon.), 1998.
Alpha Omega Alpha, Cornell Medical School (hon.), 1958.
American Industrial Hygiene Association, 1946–1958.
American Academy of Occupational Medicine, 1952.
American Federation for Clinical Research (Boston Chapter), 1953–19.38.
Industrial Medical Assoc. (Member Com. on Editorials and Publica

cations), 1957–1959.
Industrial Medical Assoc. (Member Com. on Toxicology), 1957-
American Trudeau Society, 1957-
Association of Teachers of Preventive Medicine, 1961
American College of Physicians, Fellow, 1962-
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, 1963-
Royal Society of Medicine, Affiliate, 1963.

[ocr errors]


Hardy, H. L., Clarke, H. L. and Brouhs, L., Testing physical fitness in young

women, Revue Canadienne de Biologie, vol. 2, no. 4, Oct. 1943. Hardy, H. L., The clinical significance of data accumulated in the medical care

of young women, N. Eng. J. Med., 233:811, 1945. Hardy, H. L., and Bullon, Adelaide, Analysis of body build photographs of 175

college women, Amer. J. Phys. Anthropology, 4:37, 1946. Hardy, H.L., and Feemster, Roy, Infection hepatitis in Massachusetts with a

review of present knowledge of the disease, N. Eng. J. Med., 235:147, Aug. 1,

1946. Hardy, H. L., and Tabershaw, I. R., Delayed chemical pneumonitis occurring in

workers exposed to beryllium compounds, J. Indus. Hygiene and Tox., 28:197,

1946. Hardy, H. L., New clinical syndrome, delayed chemical pneumonitis occurring

in workers exposed to beryllium compounds, Bull. X. Eng. Med Center IX, 16,

Feb., 1947. Hardy, H. L., Prevention of anthrax (correspondence), X. Eng. Med. J., p. 883,

June 5, 1917. Hardy, H. L., and Skinner, J. B., The possibility of chronic cadmium poisoning,

J. Ind. Hygiene and Tox., 29:321, 1947. Hardy, H. L., Pulmonary disease in industry. Present knowledge of delayed chemical pneumonitis occurring in workers exposed to beryllium compounds (Abstract), Reprint Trans. 43rd Annual meeting, National Tuberculosis Assn.,

1947. Hardy, H. L., and Elkins, H. B., Medical aspects of maximum allowable con

centrations : benzene, J. Ind. Hygiene and Tox., 30:186, 1948. Hardy, H. L., Delayed chemical pneumonitis in workers exposed to beryllium

compound, Am. Rer. Tuberculosis, 57: 547, 1948. Abstract also in J.A.M.A.,

138: 1197, 1948. Simmons, F. A., and Hardy, H. L., Chronic progressive infectious gangrene of

the skin: a patient with exposure to cold wave solution. Ann. Surg. 128:1112,

1948. Hardy, H. L., Mercury poisoning. Physics Today, 2: no. 11, Nov., 1949. Hamilton, Alice and Hardy, H. L., Industrial Toxicology. Paul B. Hoeber, Inc.,

New York, 574 pp., 1949. Hardy. H. L., Toxic effects of beryllium, Metals Industry, 18: 23. Trans. National

Safety Council, Oct., 1949. Hardy, H. L., Acute and chronic beryllium poisoning, AECU 569, U.S. Atomic

Energy Commission, October 1949. Hardy. H. L., Jeffries. W. McK., and Wasserman, N. M., Waddell. W. R., Thiocy.

anate effect following industrial cyanide exposure, N. Eng. J. Med. 212:968,

1950. Hardy. H. L., and Maloof, C. C., Evidence of systemic effect of tetryl, Arch. Ind.

Hyg. and Occup. Med., 1:545, 1950. Hardy, H. L., Hazards of common solvents, Physics Today, 3:15, 1950. Hardy. H. L., The character and distribution of disease in American industries

using beryllium compounds, Proc. of the Royal Soc. of Med., 44: 257, 1951.

(Paper read before Royal Society of Medicine Oct. 20. 1959). IIardy, II. L. and C. C. Maloof, Treatment of lead poisoning with sodium citrate,

Arch. Indust. Hyg. and Occ. Med., 3: 267, 1951. Hardy. H. L., F. C. Bartter and A. E. Jaffin. Metabolic study of a case of chronic

beryllium poisoning treated with ACTH, Arch. Indust. Hyg. and Occ. Med.,

3: 579, 1951. Hardy. H. L., Beryllium (Sect. X, Industrial Toxicology Chapter), Oxford Loose

Leaf Medicine 4:42, 1951. Hardy, H, L., The beryllium problems: the chronic or delayed disease. Clinical

and epidemiological aspects. Pneumoconiosis: beryllium, bauxite fumes, com

pensation. Paul B. Hoeber, New York, pp. 133–52. 1950. Hardy, H. L., Clinical evidence for the latent and additive action of benzol with

other toxic insults: report of two cases, Arhiv Za Higijenu Fada (Yugosla

vian Journal), 3. B. R. 1, pp. 1-6, 1952. Hamilton, Alice and B. T. Johnstone, reviewed by Hardy, H. L., Ionizing Radia

tion, Oxford Loose-Leaf Medicine, XXI, 663, 150-177. 1952. Hardy, H. L., Experience accumulated in 3 years of an occupational medical

clinic. Ind. Med. and Surg., 21:9, 424, 1952.

« PreviousContinue »