Opinions of Solicitor, September 15, 1914, and February 2, 1915; overruled, September 9, 1919 (D-43035, May Caramony). (See 58 I.D. 149, 154156.) Opinion of Solicitor, October 31, 1917 (D-40462); overruled so far as inconsistent, 58 I.D. 85, 92, 96. Opinion of Solicitor, February 7, 1919 (D-44083); overruled, November 4, 1921 (M-6397). (See 58 I.D. 158, 160.) Opinion of Solicitor, August 8, 1933 (M27499); overruled so far as in conflict, 54 I.D. 402. Opinion of Solicitor, June 15, 1934 (54 I.D. 517); overruled in part, Feb. 11, 1957 (M-36410). Opinion of Solicitor, May 8, 1940 (57 I.D. 124); overruled in part, 58 I.D. 562, 567. Opinion of Acting Solicitor, June 6, 1941; overruled so far as inconsistent, 60 I.D. 333. Opinion of Acting Solicitor, July 30, 1942; overruled so far as in conflict, 58 1.D. 331. (See 59 I.D. 346, 350.) Opinion of Solicitor, August 31, 1943 (M-33183); distinguished 58 I.D. 726, 729. Opinion of Solicitor, May 2, 1944 (58 I.D. 680); distinguished, 64 I.D. 141. Opinion of Solicitor, March 28, 1949 (M-35093); overruled in part, 64 I.D. 70. Opinion of Solicitor, Jan. 19, 1956 (M36378); overruled to extent inconsistent, 64 I.D. 58. Opinion of Solicitor, June 4, 1957 (M 36443); overruled in part, 65 I.D. 316. Opinion of Solicitor, July 9, 1957 (M36442); withdrawn and superseded, 65 I.D. 386, 388. Opinion of Solicitor, 64 I.D. 393 (1957); no longer followed, 66 I.D. 366. Opinion of Solicitor, Oct. 27, 1958 (M-| 36531); overruled, 69 I.D. 110. Opinion of Solicitor, July 20, 1959 (M 36531, Supp.); overruled, 69 I.D. 110. Oregon and California R.R. Co. v. Puckett (39 L.D. 169); modified, 53 I.D. 264. Oregon Central Military Wagon Road Co. v. Hart (17 L.D. 480); overruled, 18 L.D. 543. Owens et al. v. State of California (22 L.D. 369); overruled, 38 L.D. 253. Pace v. Carstarphen et al. (50 L.D. 369); distinguished, 61 I.D. 459. Pacific Slope Lode (12 L.D. 686); overruled so far as in conflict, 25 L.D. 518. Papina v. Alderson (1 B.L.P. 91); modified, 5 L.D. 256. Patterson, Charles E. (3 L.D. 260); modified, 6 L.D. 284, 624. Paul Jones Lode (28 L.D. 120); modified, 31 L.D. 359. Paul v. Wiseman (21 L.D. 12); overruled, 27 L.D. 522. Pecos Irrigation and Improvement Co. (15 L.D. 470); overruled, 18 L.D. 168, 268. Pennock, Belle L. (42 L.D. 315); vacated, 43 L.D. 66. Perry v. Central Pacific R.R. Co. (39 L.D. 5); overruled so far as in conflict, 47 L.D. 304. Phebus, Clayton (48 L.D. 128); overruled so far as in conflict, 50 L.D. 281. Phelps, W. L. (8 C.L.O. 139); overruled, 2 L.D. 854. Phillips, Alonzo (2 L.D. 321); overruled, 15 L.D. 424. Phillips v. Breazeale's Heirs (19 L.D. 573); overruled, 39 L.D. 93. Pieper, Agnes C. (35 L.D. 459); overruled, 43 L.D. 374. Pierce, Lewis W. (18 L.D. 328); va cated, 53 I.D. 447; overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 416, 422. Pietkiewicz et al. v. Richmond (29 L.D. 195); overruled, 37 L.D. 145, Pike's Peak Lode (10 L.D. 200); overruled in part, 20 L.D. 204. Pike's Peake Lode (14 L.D. 47); overruled, 20 L.D. 204. Popple, James (12 L.D. 433); over-| Rogers, Fred B. (47 L.D. 325); varuled, 13 L.D. 588. cated, 53 I.D. 649. Powell, D. C. (6 L.D. 302); modified, Rogers, Horace B. (10 L.D. 29); over 15 L.D. 477. Prange, Christ C., and William C. ruled, 14 L.D. 321. Rogers v. Atlantic & Pacific R.R. Co. (6 L.D. 565); overruled so far as in conflict, 8 L.D. 165. Rogers v. Lukens (6 L.D. 111); overruled, 8 L.D. 110. (See 9 L.D. 360.) Prescott, Henrietta P. (46 L.D. 486); Romero v. Widow of Knox (48 L.D. overruled, 51 L.D. 287. Pringle, Wesley (13 L.D. 519); overruled, 29 L.D. 599. Provensal, Victor H. (30 L.D. 616); overruled, 35 L.D. 399. Prue, Widow of Emanuel (6 L.D. 436); vacated, 33 L.D. 409. Pugh, F. M., et al. (14 L.D. 274); in effect vacated, 232 U.S. 452. Puyallup Allotments (20 L.D. 157) ; modified, 29 L.D. 628. Ramsey, George L., Heirs of Edwin C. 32); overruled so far as in conflict, 49 L.D. 244. Roth, Gottlieb (50 L.D. 196); modified, 50 L.D. 197. Rough Rider and Other Lode Claims (41 L.D. 242, 255); vacated, 42 L.D. 584. St. Clair, Frank (52 L.D. 597); modified, 53 I.D. 194. *St. Paul, Minneapolis and Manitoba Ry. Co. (8 L.D. 255); modified, 13 L.D. 354. (See 32 L.D. 21.) St. Paul, Minneapolis and Manitoba Ry. Co. v. Hagen (20 L.D. 249); overruled, 25 L.D. 86. Rancho Alisal (1 L.D. 173); overruled, St. Paul, Minneapolis and Manitoba 5 L.D. 320. Rankin, James D., et al. (7 L.D. 411); overruled, 35 L.D. 32. Rankin, John M. (20 L.D. 272); re versed, 21 L.D. 404. Rebel Lode (12 L.D. 683); overruled, Ry. Co. v. Fogelberg (29 L.D. 291); vacated, 30 L.D. 191. Salsberry, Carroll (17 L.D. 170); over- Sangre de Cristo and Maxwell Land Sante Fe Pacific R.R. Co. v. Peterson Reid, Bettie H., Lucille H. Pipkin (61 | *Sayles, Henry P. (2 L.D. 88); modiI.D. 1); overruled, 61 I.D. 355. fied, 6 L.D. 797. (See 37 L.D. 330.) Rialto No. 2 Placer Mining Claim (34 Schweitzer v. Hilliard et al. (19 L.D. L.D. 44); overruled, 37 L.D. 250. Rico Town Site (1 L.D. 556); modified, 5 L.D. 256. Rio Verde Canal Co. (26 L.D. 381); vacated, 27 L.D. 421. Roberts v. Oregon Central Military Road Co. (19 L.D. 591); overruled, 31 L.D. 174. 294); overruled so far as in conflict, 26 L.D. 639. Serrano v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (6 C.L.O. 93); overruled, 1 L.D. 380. Serry, John J. (27 L.D. 330); overruled so far as in conflict, 59 I.D. 416, 422. Shale Oil Company. (See 55 I.D. 287.) Robinson, Stella G. (12 L.D. 443); Shanley v. Moran (1 L.D. 162); over overruled, 13 L.D. 1. ruled, 15 L.D. 424. Shineberger, Joseph (8 L.D. 231); over- State of California v. Pierce (3 C.L.O. ruled, 9 L.D. 202. 118); modified, 2 L.D. 854. Silver Queen Lode (16 L.D. 186); over- State of California v. Smith (5 L.D. ruled, 57 I.D. 63. Simpson, Lawrence W. (35 L.D. 399, 609); modified, 36 L.D. 205. Sipchen v. Ross (1 L.D. 634); modified, 4 L.D. 152. Smead v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (21 L.D. 432); vacated, 29 L.D. 135. Snook, Noah A., et al. (41 L.D. 428); overruled so far as in conflict, 43 L.D. 364. Sorli v. Berg (40 L.D. 259); overruled, 42 L.D. 557. L.D. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (15 L.D. 460); reversed, 18 L.D. 275. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (28 281); recalled, 32 L.D. 51. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. (33 L.D. 89); recalled, 33 L.D. 528. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. v. Bruns (31 L.D. 272); vacated, 37 L.D. 243. South Star Lode (17 L.D. 280); overruled, 20 L.D. 204; 48 L.D. 523. Spaulding v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (21 L.D. 57) ; overruled, 31 L.D. 151. Spencer, James (6 L.D. 217); modified, 6 L.D. 772; 8 L.D. 467. 543); overruled so far as in conflict, 18 L.D. 343. State of Colorado (7 L.D. 490); overruled, 9 L.D. 408. State of Florida (17 L.D. 355); reversed, 19 L.D. 76. State of Florida (47 L.D. 92, 93); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 291. State of Louisiana (8 L.D. 126); modified, 9 L.D. 157. State of Louisiana (24 L.D. 231); vacated, 26 L.D. 5. State of Louisiana (47 L.D. 366); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 291. State of Louisiana (48 L.D. 201); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 291. State of Nebraska (18 L.D. 124); overruled, 28 L.D. 358. State of Nebraska v. Dorrington (2 C.L.L. 467); overruled so far as in conflict, 26 L.D. 123. State of New Mexico (46 L.D. 217); State of New Mexico (49 L.D. 314); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. overruled, 54 I.D. 159. Spruill, Lelia May (50 L.D. 549); over- State of Utah (45 L.D. 551); overruled, ruled, 52 L.D. 339. Standard Shales Products Co. (52 L.D. 522); overruled so far as in conflict, 53 I.D. 42. 48 L.D. 98. *Stevenson, Heirs of v. Cunningham (32 L.D. 650); overruled so far as in conflict, 41 L.D. 119. ( (See 43 L.D. 196.) State of California (14 L.D. 253); va- Stewart et al. v. Rees et al. (21 L.D. cated, 23 L.D. 230. State of California (15 L.D. 10); overruled, 23 L.D. 423. State of California (19 L.D. 585); vacated, 28 L.D. 57. State of California (22 L.D. 428); overruled, 32 L.D. 34. State of California (32 L.D. 346); va- | cated, 50 L.D. 628. (See 37 L.D. 499 and 46 L.D. 396.) State of California (44 L.D. 118); overruled, 48 L.D. 98. 446); overruled so far as in conflict, 29 L.D. 401. Stirling, Lillie E. (39 L.D. 346); overruled, 46 L.D. 110. Stockley, Thomas J. (44 L.D. 178, 180); vacated, 260 U.S. 532. (See 49 L.D. 460, 461, 492.) Strain, A. G. (40 L.D. 108); overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 51. Streit, Arnold (T-476 (Ir.)), August 26, 1952, unreported; overruled, 62 I.D. 12. State of California (44 L.D. 468); over- Stricker, Lizzie (15 L.D. 74) ; overruled ruled, 48 L.D. 98. State of California v. Moccettini (19 L.D. 359); overruled, 31 L.D. 335. so far as in conflict, 18 L.D. 283. Stump, Alfred M. et al. (39 L.D. 437); vacated, 42 L.D. 566. L.D. 414); overruled, 25 L.D. 233. Tupper v. Schwarz (2 L.D. 623); overruled, 6 L.D. 624. Sumner v. Roberts (23 L.D. 201); over- | Tucker v. Florida Ry. & Nav. Co. (19 ruled so far as in conflict, 41 L.D. 173. Sweeney v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (20 L.D. 394); overruled, 28 L.D. 174. *Sweet, Eri P. (2 C.L.O. 18); overruled, 41 L.D. 129. (See 42 L.D. 313.) Sweeten v. Stevenson (2 B.L.P. 42); overruled so far as in conflict; 3 L.D. 248. Taft v. Chapin (14 L.D. 593); over ruled, 17 L.D. 414. Taggart, William M. (41 L.D. 282); overruled, 47 L.D. 370. Talkington's Heirs v. Hempfling (2 L.D. 46); overruled, 14 L.D. 200. Tate, Sarah J. (10 L.D. 469); over- Taylor, Josephine, et al. (A-21994), The Departmental supplemental deci- Thorstenson, Even (45 L.D. 96); overruled so far as in conflict, 47 L.D. 258. Tieck v. McNeil (48 L.D. 158); modified, 49 L.D. 260. Toles v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co. et al. (39 L.D. 371); overruled so far as in conflict, 45 L.D. 96. Turner v. Cartwright (17 L.D. 414); modified, 21 L.D. 40. Turner v. Lang (1 C.L.O. 51); modified, 5 L.D. 256. Tyler, Charles (26 L.D. 699); overruled, 35 L.D. 411. Ulin v. Colby (24 L.D. 311); overruled, 35 L.D. 549. Union Pacific R.R. Co. (33 L.D. 89); recalled, 33 L.D. 528. United States v. Bush (13 L.D. 529); overruled, 18 L.D. 441. United States v. Central Pacific Ry. Co. (52 L.D. 81); modified, 52 L.D. 235. United States v. Dana (18 L.D. 161); modified, 28 L.D. 45. United States v. Keith V. O'Leary et al. (63 I.D. 341); distinguished, 64 I.D. United States v. M. W. Mouat et al. (60 Veatch, Heir of Natter (46 L.D. 496) ; Vine, James (14 L.D. 527); modified, Tomkins, H. H. (41 L.D. 516); over- Wagoner v. Hanson (50 L.D. 355); ruled, 51 L.D. 27. overruled, 56 I.D. 325, 328. 41 L.D. 637. Traganza, Mertie C. (40 L.D. 300); Wahe, John (41 L.D. 127); modified, overruled, 42 L.D. 612. Traugh v. Ernst (2 L.D. 212); over- Walker v. Prosser (17 L.D. 85); reruled, 3 L.D. 98. versed, 18 L.D. 425. Tripp v. Dumphy (28 L.D. 14); modi- Walker v. Southern Pacific R.R. Co. fied, 40 L.D. 128. (24 L.D. 172); overruled, 28 L.D. 174. Tripp v. Stewart (7 C.L.O. 39); modi- Walters, David (15 L.D. 136); revoked, fied, 6 L.D. 795. 24 L.D. 58. Warren v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (22 L.D. 568); overruled so far as in conflict, 49 L.D. 391. Wasmund v. Northern Pacific R.R. Co. (23 L.D. 445); vacated, 29 L.D. 224. Wass v. Milward (5 L.D. 349); no longer followed. (See 44 L.D. 72 and unreported case of Ebersold v. Dickson, September 25, 1918, D-36502.) Waterhouse, William W. (9 L.D. 131); overruled, 18 L.D. 586. Watson, Thomas E. (4 L.D. 169); re called, 6 L.D. 71. Weathers, Allen E., Frank N. Hartley (A-25128), May 27, 1949, unreported; overruled in part, 62 I.D. 62. Weaver, Francis D. (53 I.D. 179); overruled so far as in conflict, 55 I.D. 290. Weber, Peter (7 L.D. 476); overruled, 9 L.D. 150. Wickstrom v. Calkins (20 L.D. 459); modified, 21 L.D. 553; overruled, 22 L.D. 392. Widow of Emanuel Prue (6 L.D. 436); vacated, 33 L.D. 409. Wiley, George P. (36 L.D. 305); modified so far as in conflict, 36 L.D. 417. Wilkerson, Jasper N. (41 L.D. 138); overruled, 50 L.D. 614. (See 42 L.D. 313.) Wilkins, Benjamin C. (2 L.D. 129); modified, 6 L.D. 797. Willamette Valley and Cascade Mountain Wagon Road Co. v. Bruner (22 L.D. 654); vacated, 26 L.D. 357. Williams, John B., Richard and Ger trude Lamb (61 I.D. 31); overruled so far as in conflict, 61 I.D. 185. Willingbeck, Christian P. (3 L.D. 383); modified, 5 L.D. 409. Weisenborn, Ernest (42 L.D. 533); Willis, Cornelius et al. (47 L.D. 135); overruled, 43 L.D. 395. Werden v. Schlecht (20 L.D. 523); overruled so far as in conflict, 24 L.D. 45. Western Pacific Ry. Co. (40 L.D. 411; 41 L.D. 599); overruled, 43 L.D. 410. Wheaton v. Wallace (24 L.D. 100); modified, 34 L.D. 383. White, Anderson (Probate 13570-35); overruled, 58 I.D. 149, 157. White, Sarah V. (40 L.D. 630); overruled in part, 46 L.D. 56. Whitten et al. v. Read (49 L.D. 253, 260; 50 L.D. 10); vacated, 53 I.D. 447. overruled, 49 L.D. 461. Willis, Eliza (22 L.D. 426); overruled, 26 L.D. 436. *Wilson v. Heirs of Smith (37 L.D. 519); overruled so far as in conflict, 41 L.D. 119. (See 43 L.D. 196.) Witbeck v. Hardeman (50 L.D. 413) ; overruled so far as in conflict, 51 L.D. 36. Wright et al. v. Smith (44 L.D. 226); in effect overruled so far as in conflict, 49 L.D. 374. Zimmerman v. Brunson (39 L.D. 310); overruled, 52 L.D. 714. NOTE. The abbreviations used in this title refer to the following publications: “B.L.P.” to Brainard's Legal Precedents in Land and Mining Cases, vols. 1 and 2; "C.L.L." to Copp's Public Land Laws, edition of 1875, 1 volume; edition of 1882, 2 volumes; edition of 1890, 2 volumes; "C.L.O." to Copp's Land Owner, vols. 1-18; "L. and R." to records of the former Division of Lands and Railroads; "L.D." to the Land Decisions of the Department of the Interior, vols. 1-52; "I.D." to Decisions of the Department of the Interior, beginning with vol. 53.— EDITOR. |